The Music Link Review game

[Theodor]

I have seen so many signatures in here with "My music" or "NameProductions.com" but how many people ever visit them?

So this is the idea . You listen to a composition of the person above you and you write down :
Title of song you heard
Does it overally work as a song Yes/no
Constructive comments/things you would do ( eq ,harmony ,structure , ideas etc)
Rating

Afterwards you write down your own music link so the next replier takes a listen to yours and so on .

If a page is not working properly, you say it and the person gets another row in the game later silently so the flow is uninterrupted.

All ready? Set - GO !

[88fingers]

Hi Theodor,
This is a cool Idea I'll give it a go.

Since I couldn't find a link for any of your music I will post mine first.
I am posting the whole site so that someone may just pick any piece they like and comment on it. " I just hope they don't pick "Harpsichord and flute trio" somehow when I uploaded it, the file got all messed up and it doesn't sound right.

This should be fun.

http://www.pac007.com/Pack007list.htm

Note: Most of the pieces are .wma but the last few pieces at the bottom of the page are .mp3

[Theodor]

88fingers

I chose "Tragedy, the Fallen hero."

Does it work as a song : Yes

Comments : I really liked the song and the overall feeling the heavy funeral type brass gives ( my cousin btw next to me is humming along the theme now that i am playing it again ) . The only things i would change is the snare which seems to be a bit out of the mix, maybe a bit reverb would send it to the background . I don't think the large chord at the end is nescesary , maybe just the drums fading out would be better in my oppinion .

Overall : Really good, i give it a 8.4/10 for the music stand-alone , playing along a movie scene for the same context "Fallen Hero" i give it 8.9/10

My link is : http://www.soundclick.com/bands/9/journeyofsolsmusic.htm

Please exclude "Intro" from your choices :)

[Alan Lastufka]

Theodor,

I chose "Abandoned" from your link.

Does it work as a song: Yes, as a long prog rock track, just as it's billed. :)

Overall: I love prog rock (ie: Rush, Dream Theater...) and while your's wasn't as heavy it still presented some of the ingredients that drew me to prog rock in the beginning: a sense of something larger, not just a three minute pop tune.

My link: www.alanjoseph.com (http://www.alanjoseph.com) for my personal music - there are two pages, an electronic music page and an orchestral music page...