Vote for Orchestration Challenge 16

[Garritan]

It's time to vote for Orchestral Challenge #16

As the winner of Challenge 15, Theme Meister Owen (englishgent) created the theme for this round.

We received 3 entries this time (perhaps because of Spring break).

Many thanks to Owen for the theme. Thanks again to Sean for putting this all together and hosting the entries. And a big thanks to all of the participants.

This is a "one-vote-per-person" poll. We'll keep the voting open for about two weeks.

The choices are:

Entry 1 - http://www.wizardwalk.com/duel2/Entry01_Chall16.mp3
Entry 2 - http://www.wizardwalk.com/duel2/Entry02_Chall16.mp3
Entry 3 - http://www.wizardwalk.com/duel2/Entry03_Chall16.mp3


Have fun and good luck!

Gary Garritan

[sanyarem]

Wow. I know this is said basically every challenge, but those were all amazing!!!
I'm kinda glad I didn't enter, I don't think i could've topped any of those! Great job for those who took the time to enter, and thanks englishgent for the fabulous (and obviously versatile) theme!

[DanielB]

Awesome! The vote is up!

Good luck!

[RichR]

Celtic and awesome. Nice renditions everyone! I am sorry I couldn't get in on the fun this time. I had major issues with my computer, OS hard drive, graphics card and audio interface. Other than that, all is going just peachy.

I have most of my issues resolved through 2 weeks of formating hard drives and re-installing software (now where is that authorization code for GPO anyway?)

I know this is a small entry group, but we have had that before. What I hear may be a small group of compositions but WOW they are great to listen to. Congratulations to all and good luck!

[etLux]

Nice job, all!

Remember, everybody, vote early, vote often.

Best,



David
www.DavidSosnowski.com

[AlanPerkins]

Well done everyone!

[englishgent]

Bumping it to see if anyone else wants to vote.

It's less than 7 minutes of listening for all entries combined, so let's support all the participants hard work!

Owen

[DanielB]

Bumping it to see if anyone else wants to vote.

It's less than 7 minutes of listening for all entries combined, so let's support all the participants hard work!

Owen

Yes, it got to the second page rather quickly. D:

Is the unusually small amount of entries affecting the amount of voters? Hm.

EDIT: Just realized it hasn't even been up for a week yet...

[rolifer]

Well Done to all!!

All 3 entries are very well conceived and executed.

Ron

[holderofthehorns]

Since this is all about us learning more about the tools, I would like to guess that the first and third compositions above were accomplished with notation software. The second was "played" on a keyboard controller.

Would it be available to find out if this is true when the voting is over?

Recap:
Songs 1 and 3 were done with Notation software.
Song 2 was done with a controller.

All the compositions were very good, but the "performance" of #2 was noticably more expressive. Hence, the guess about Notation vs Controllers.